Playlists
Genesis in 20 Songs
Attempting to chart Genesis’ career in 20 songs is a daunting prospect, given the band’s recorded output – both in quality and in quantity. We’ve set ourselves the challenge of choosing 20 songs that tell the band’s musical autobiography from their own genesis to their most recent releases, spanning six decades.
Where better place to start than at the very beginning, with their very first single release for Decca Records, back in 1968. ‘The Silent Sun’ preceded the recording of their debut album, From Genesis to Revelation that began in the autumn of the same year. At this point the band was Tony Banks on piano and backing vocals; Anthony Phillips, acoustic guitar, backing vocals, Mike Rutherford on bass, backing vocals, drummer, Chris Stewart and Peter Gabriel on lead vocals.
There is arguably no greater musical forward step by any band than from ‘The Silent Sun’ to ‘The Knife’ that was featured on the album Trespass that was recorded over two years later. John Mayhew had become the band’s third drummer over this time and Phil Collins replaced Mayhew shortly before Trespass was released. The time changes, shifts in the musical motifs and the obvious complexities of the music and lyrics were a clarion call to the band’s growing number of fans. It became a key song in their live shows and built to a climax of rabid intensity when they performed it live; so much so that on one occasion Gabriel jumped off the stage and broke his ankle.
The accident was at Friars in Aylesbury in June 1971 and according to Steve Hackett who had recently joined the band to replace Phillips, “People didn’t realise it wasn’t part of the show, he was sitting on the floor saying ‘why didn’t anyone come to help me?”’ Eventually, it was Richard MacPhail who was mixing up front who realised there was a problem. I remember him stoically sitting there in agony at the end of the gig waiting for the ambulance to take him off. Then we did a few gigs with him in a wheelchair and a cast. Not surprisingly that didn’t really work.”
November 1971 saw the release of Nursery Cryme whose opening track was the monumental ‘The Musical Box’. The lyrics, written by Gabriel, are about two children in a country house – a girl, Cynthia, who kills the boy, Henry, by taking his head off with a croquet mallet. The song’s theme inspired the album artwork and remained in their live shows for the next two decades.
Eleven months after Nursery Cryme, Foxtrot was released and the opening track is another song that became a firm fan favourite. The inspiration behind the title of ‘Watcher In The Skies’ is taken from John Keats’ 1817 poem “On First Looking into Chapman’s Home; “Then felt I like some watcher of the skies. When a new planet swims into his ken.” Tony Bank’s Mellotron powers this number along and it too is much loved by every fan of the band, but it also serves to show what makes their sound so appealing and so evocative. The lyrics are by Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford and they were inspired to write them prior to a gig in Naples in April 1972; they were looking at a deserted airfield that got them thinking about what an empty Earth would look like to an alien from space.
The centrepiece of Foxtrot is ‘Supper’s Ready’ and we decided to include the version from Genesis’ 1977 live album Seconds Out. When asked what the song was about, Peter Gabriel said it was, “a personal journey which ends up walking through scenes from Revelation in the Bible…I’ll leave it at that.” The 1977 live recording is from the Wind & Wuthering tour, after Gabriel had left the band.
A year, almost to the day, after Foxtrot, Selling England By The Pound became their fifth studio album and it includes ‘I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)’ which has the distinction of being the first Genesis single to make the charts. Released ahead of the album it was a slow burn as it did not chart until April 1974, whereafter it managed to make #21 on the bestseller list. While Genesis at this point were not thought of as a singles band it’s testament to the song that it did as well as it did, even having the dance group Pan’s People choreographing a routine for it on the BBC’s Top of the Pops TV show.
For many, it’s ‘Firth of Fifth’ that is the standout song from Selling England… With its beautifully crafted Tony Banks’s neo-classical piano intro and Steve Hackett’s wonderful guitar solo it is one of the pinnacles of Prog. And the title? A playful re-arrangement of the name of the body of water that separates Edinburgh and East Lothian from Fife in Scotland – it’s called The Firth of Forth.
1974’s The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway is the last of the band’s albums to feature Peter Gabriel as Genesis’ frontman. A tour-de-force and a concept album that tells the surreal story of a half Puerto Rican juvenile delinquent named Rael in New York City, who faces nightmarish dangers while attempting to rescue his brother John. ‘The Carpet Crawlers’ is such an evocative song that continued to be a mainstay of the band’s live shows even after Gabriel’s departure.
1976’s A Trick of The Tail was the first post-Gabriel album and it features Phil Collins on lead vocals, but even so it was impossible not to pick ‘Los Endos’ as the track from this album, an album that certainly divides opinion among fans. It’s largely instrumental and this towering riff-laden track became an important part of the band’s live show. While some fans preferred what went before this was a commercial milestone for the band. According to Tony Banks A Trick of the Tail doubled the band’s previous albums’ sales.
Wind and Wuthering released in the last week of 1976 was another pivotal album. It was the first to crack the Billboard top 30 album chart, and it included ‘Your Own Special Way’ which was the band’s first hit single in America, albeit a lowly #62 on the Billboard Hot 100. Written by Mike Rutherford it pulls off the impressive trick of being a credible rock love song with pure-pop sensibilities.
Every fan knows that the title of the band’s 1978 album, …And then There Were Three refers to the departure of Steve Hackett to pursue his solo career. It was a departure to from the band’s old ways of writing material, it had a ‘sound’ all of its own that record buyers loved, propelling it to No.3 in the UK album charts, helped by the success of ‘Follow You, Follow Me’, However, the track that we’ve chosen as the eleventh of our twenty songs is the brilliant ‘The Lady Lies’. If one song characterises this record it is this. Tony Bank’s song harks back to Genesis of old but it sounds new, fresh and exciting. Banks uses a battery of keyboards to produce a layered effect that sounds BIG and with a great Collins vocal makes this irresistible.
Two years later came Duke, an album that almost made the top 10 in America, but did make the top of the UK’s best seller list; it was helped by ‘Turn It On Again’ a single that made No.8 in Britain. The single was a minor hit in the US helped by the video that featured on the first day of MTV broadcasting in the US. Following a No.1 record is always challenging but Genesis repeated their success in the UK, while in the US Abacab became their first top 10 album when it made No.7 in late 1981. The album’s title track is a signature piece for the band and the edited single version went to #9 in the UK and the Billboard top 30.
1982 brought forth another ‘in concert’ album from Genesis; Three Sides Live is exactly that, three sides of the LP were live recordings, mostly from a 1981 autumn tour along with one side of studio recordings. ‘Duchess’ recorded at Nassau Coliseum, Long Island in November 1981 was originally a track from Duke.
In January 1984 Genesis finally made the top 10 of America’s Hot 100. ‘That’s All’ from their eponymous 1983 album is very Beatlesque in structure and sound. Like the best of the Fab Four this song is extremely catchy and easy to see why it was such a big hit on American radio; in Britain it only made No.16. Two years later, in July 1986, Genesis topped the Billboard Hot 100 with the title song of their album, Invisible Touch; the single was knocked from the top spot by Peter Gabriel’s ‘Sledgehammer’.
Two songs from Invisible Touch? Well, it would be impossible not to include ‘Throwing It All Away’ which was the second single to be taken from the album; the single made No.4 on the Hot 100 while the album made No.3 and in so doing became the most successful of Genesis’ albums in America. ‘Throwing It All Away’ has such a great hook, another in their expanding series of pop-rock classics; if we had a list of 21 songs we might be tempted to include ‘Tonight, Tonight, Tonight’ as well.
1991’s album offering was We Can’t Dance and the de facto title track, ‘I Can’t Dance’ proved to be another top 10 hit in America and while the single was not quite as successful in Britain it helped to propel the album to the top of the UK bestseller list. It would be six years before another Genesis album came along and this was one without Phil Collins involvement. 1997’s Calling All Stations featured Rutherford and Banks with former Stiltskin vocalist; Ray Wilson and we’ve picked the excellent, ‘The Dividing Line’.
In 2007 Genesis was back on tour, with Phil Collins once again back in the fold and the band’s sixth live album, Live Over Europe 2007, was the product of the tour. ‘Mama’ was a tough one to leave off the list from their Genesis album, the original studio record from which ‘Mama’ was taken. When the studio version came out as a single in 1983 it reached No.4 on the UK charts, making it their most successful single on home territory. Phil Collins vocal on this live version is definitive, a song full of passion, menace and theatrical flourishes.
What a band. What a body of work. It was hard to pick just 20 tracks, there are many classics sides that we’ve had to leave out of our list of 20 songs, but we think it tells Genesis’ musical autobiography. So next time anyone asks you what makes Genesis so great, play these 20 songs…and play them loud.
1.The Silent Sun (First single) 1968
2. The Knife (Trespass) 1970
3. The Musical Box (Nursery Cryme) 1971
4. Watcher of the Skies (Foxtrot) 1972
5. I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe) (Selling England By The Pound) (1st UK hit single) 1973
6. Firth of Fifth (Selling England By The Pound) 1973
7. The Carpet Crawlers (The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway) 1974
8. Los Endos (A Trick of the Tail) 1976
9. Your Own Special Way (Wind & Wuthering) (1st US Hit single) 1977
10. Supper’s Ready (Seconds Out) 1977
11. The Lady Lies (And Then There Were Three) 1978
12. Turn It On Again (Duke) 1980
13. Abacab (Abacab) 1981
14. Duchess (Three Sides Live) 1982
15. That’s All (Genesis) (1st US top 10 single) 1983
16. Invisible Touch (Invisible touch) (Only US No.1 single) 1986
17. Throwing It All Away (Invisible Touch) 1986
18. I Can’t Dance (We Can’t Dance) 1991
19. The Dividing Line (Calling All Stations) 1997
20. Mama (Live Over Europe) 2007
Genesis on iTunes
Listen to all 20 songs on Spotify
Explore our dedicated Genesis Artist Page
Brent Bollmeier
March 11, 2015 at 12:54 pm
Perhaps “Supper’s Ready”?, not “Super’s”? 🙂
Hernan
March 11, 2015 at 12:55 pm
The Dividing Line it isn’t deserves to belong to this list.
Brent Bollmeier
March 11, 2015 at 1:11 pm
I’d have put “Uncertain Weather” there.
Anthony
March 11, 2015 at 1:01 pm
I almost agree completely with your choices. Just throw “Thowing it all away” away (pun intended), and replace it with “Domino”.
Matt Sanders
March 11, 2015 at 1:35 pm
So where is “Musical Box”???
Jack Soffalot
March 11, 2015 at 1:50 pm
Er, at number 3?
arturo
March 11, 2015 at 1:51 pm
The Lamia???????
Martyn Pitt
March 11, 2015 at 2:08 pm
I saw them on the Seconds Out tour in 1977 and can still picture them doing Supper’s Ready even now. Having said that, the studio version from Foxtrot must surely take precedence here?
Soren
March 11, 2015 at 2:21 pm
Good list, but…:
Lose “Supper’s Ready”, replace w/ “Afterglow” (Seconds Out)
Where’s “Robbery, Assault and Battery”? Great Phil Collins showcase (Trick of the Tail).
Lose “Mama”, replace w/ “Home by the Sea” (Genesis, 1983)
“The Carpet Crawlers” is my favorite track on “Lamb”, but no title track? Wow.
“Keep It Dark” should have made the list.
Vladimir
March 11, 2015 at 2:44 pm
good list alas it is not available in Russia… ? I think it is the sanctions against me personally… 🙂 Just a joke… there are a lot of people that love Genesis in Russia… the songs “the moonlit knight”, “jesus he knows me”, “calling all stations” are my favorite… cheers!
Javier
March 11, 2015 at 2:53 pm
1. Stagnation (1970)
2. Mudical Box (1971)
3. Sippers Ready (1972)
4. Firth of Fifth (1973)
5. Cinema Show (1973)
6. In the Cage (1974)
7. Carpet Crawlers (1974)
8. Dance on Volcano (1976)
9. Afterglow (1977)
10. Follow You follow Me (1978)
11. Duchess (1980)
12. Behibd The Lines (1980)
13. Abacab (1981)
14. Mama (1983)
15. Home by hge Sea (1983)
16. Land of Confusion (1986)
17. Tonight, Tonight, Tonight (1986)
18. Domino (1986)
19. No Son of Mine (1991)
20. Dividing Line (1997)
Adrienne
March 11, 2015 at 2:57 pm
I almost completely disagree wholeheartedly with this list. With the exception of a few choices primarily in the early part of their career, far better choices could’ve been made in the latter portion which would showcase them still as a progressive rock band, not a pop band. Any true fan also knows it’s Watcher of the Skies” not “Watcher in the Skies”. Disappointed in this article.
Helena
March 11, 2015 at 5:06 pm
Have been lucky enough to see Genesis some 20 times, including Knebworth and Hollywood Bowl!
With Peter Gabriel;
Cinema Show
IT
The best top 5 albums with or without Peter Gabriel includes Trick of the Tail and Wind and Wuthering, so included on that list would have to be;
Blood on the Rooftops
Mad Man Moon
Al
March 4, 2016 at 1:20 pm
I think so too.
Theresa D. Brown
March 11, 2015 at 5:41 pm
Well written article and I do agree with you choices. I, however, would have chosen, Deep in the Motherlode for And Then There Were Three.
James Doyle
March 11, 2015 at 9:25 pm
The first song on the And Then There Were Three tour in Chicago was Deep In The Motherlode and I was surprised by the grand reaction. I felt like I was among thousands of close friends because the album was released just before the tour and the reaction was like it was an old favorite!
Rob Neal
March 11, 2015 at 8:31 pm
The latter half is dross.
I also cannot believe they put that turgid “Your own special way” on instead of “Afterglow”
Massimo
March 11, 2015 at 9:48 pm
My list
1. White Mountain
2. The Return of the Giant Hogweed
3. Can-Utility and the Coast Liners
4. Supper’s Ready
5. The Fountain of Salamis
6. Dancing with the Moonlight Night
7. Firth of Fifth
8. Lamia
9. Anyway
10. Counting out time
11. The Light Dies Down On Broadway
12. It
13. Dance on a Volcano
14. Ripples
15. Squonk
16. Eleventh Earl of Mar
17. Blood on the Rooftops
18. Many too Many
19. Invisible Touch
20. You’re no Son of Mine
Steven Jackson
March 12, 2015 at 12:18 am
1) Silent Sun
2) Musical Box
3) Watcher of the Skies
4) Supper’s Ready
5) I Know What I Like
6) Firth of Fifth
7) Cinemshow
8) Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
9) Carpet Crawlers
10) Entangled
11) Ripples
12) Blood on the Rooftops
13) Afterglow
14) Burning Rope
15) Follow You Follow Me
16) Turn it on Again
17) Abacab
18) Mama
19) Invisible Touch
20) No Son of Mine
Minocher Vania
March 12, 2015 at 12:29 am
1973, living in Switzerland, a school friend of mine introduced me to ” Live”. Never had heard anything like it before, even though I was an ELP and YES fan. Genesis was so unique, ” Watchers of The Skies” was brilliant ! Saw them perform “The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway” 1975 in Bern, Switzerland and a couple of times later in the US.
Martín Rodriguez
March 12, 2015 at 5:01 am
I rather the progressive line of the songs
David Barnett
March 12, 2015 at 8:40 am
A great idea to do such a list, but I’m sure every Genesis fan has his/her own favourites so there will always be disagreements. For me, Genesis can be summed up in 3 “pieces”;
1. Firth of Fifth from Selling England by the Pound. Steve Hackett “owns” that guitar solo, and sorry Daryl Steurmer, great guitarist that you are, you will never play it as good.
2. Suppers Ready from Three Sides Live – I actually think Phil’s vocals are better than Peter’s original
3. The Cage/Cinema Show/Afterglow medley from Three Sides Live – quite simply prog rock nirvana!
Brent Bollmeier
March 12, 2015 at 1:34 pm
Did you mean from Seconds Out, or is there another version of 3SL with Supper’s Ready on it?
Erik
March 12, 2015 at 3:59 pm
OK, best I could do is 22. If you put a gun to my head, I’d drop Lamb and Harold from the list, I guess. Sorry, I don’t think any songs from the last three (or And Then There Were Three…) rate with these. Just one man’s list…
1. The Knife
2. The Musical Box
3. Harold the Barrel
4. Watcher of the Skies
5. Supper’s Ready
6. Dancin’ in the Moonlit Knight
7. I Know What I Like
8. Firth of Fifth
9. Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
10. Carpet Crawlers
11. Colony of Slippermen
12. In the Cage
13. Squonk
14. Ripples
15. Eleventh Earl of Mar
16. Unquiet Slumbers for the Sleepers…
17. Afterglow
18. Turn it On Again
19. Dodo/Lurker
20. Another Record
21. Mama
22. It’s Gonna Get Better
Scott
March 12, 2015 at 4:20 pm
After reading all the comments and all the other songs that have been suggested, I believe the list should be 40-50 songs long. You just can’t do it in 20.
Robert
March 12, 2015 at 4:54 pm
I Like all their songs and their solo albums BIG TIME GENESIS FAN
Judith Rovira
March 12, 2015 at 6:32 pm
I love Genesis ❤ and love Phil Collins
rob
March 13, 2015 at 3:09 pm
Here’s my 20 for what its worth
1. The Musical Box
2. Watcher of the Skies
3. Supper’s Ready
4. I Know What I Like
5 Cinema Show
6 Dancing with The Moonlit Knight
7.It
8. In The Cage
9.Ripples
10. Squonk or The Knife
11. Afterglow
12. Snowbound
13. Follow You Follow Me
14. Behind The Lines
15. Turn It On Again
16. Throwing It All Away
17. Hold On My Heart
18. It’s Gonna Get Better
19. Man On The Corner
20. Abacab
MarkPetersen
August 9, 2016 at 7:28 pm
Here’s my list in no particular order:
1.Firth of Fifth
2.The Knife
3.The Musical Box
4.The Return Of The Giant Hogweed
5.Watcher Of The Skies
6.Get’em Out By Friday
7.Supper’s Ready
8.Dancing With The Moonlit Knight
9.Fly On A Windshield
10.Counting Out Time
11.Lilywhite Lilith
12.Riding The Scree
13.Robbery ,Assault and Battery
14 .Los Endos
15….In That Quiet Earth
16.The Cinema Show
17.Stagnation
18.Can-Utility and the Coastliners
19.Dance on a Volcano
20.One for the Vine
John Michaelson
February 10, 2017 at 4:33 pm
My two cents (in no particular order):
1. White Mountain
2. Home By The Sea
3. Feeding The Fire
4. Fountain of Salmacis
5. Follow You, Follow Me
6. Squonk
7. A Trick Of The Tail
8. That’s All
9. The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
10. Tonight, Tonight, Tonight
11. Abacab
12. Musical Box
13. Turn It On Again
14. No Son Of Mine
15. Get ‘Em Out By Friday (from Genesis Live)
16. Dodo/Lurker
17. Your Own Special Way
18. Stagnation
19. In The Glow Of The Night
20. Can-utility And The Coastliners
Honorable Mentions: “Misunderstanding” and “Land Of Confusion
Patricio
February 10, 2017 at 7:28 pm
This my list
1) Silent Sun
2) Musical Box
3) Watcher of the Skies
4) Supper’s Ready
5) I Know What I Like
6) The Lamia
7) Carpet Crawlers
8) Robbery assault and battery
9) Squonk
10) Blood on the Rooftops
11) What Gorilla
12) Burning Rope
13) Follow You Follow Me
14) Turn it on Again
15) Dukes travels
16) Dodo
17) In the cage medley
18) Mama
19) Domino
20) Driving the last spike
Mike
February 10, 2017 at 8:02 pm
Surely ‘The Cinema Show’ should be in anyone’s top 20 list of all time songs of ANY/ALL bands – not just a Genesis – unless of course you haven’t really listened to it 🙂 it’s quintessential Genesis and the last few minutes of keyboard n drums is as good as it gets!
Dave
February 11, 2017 at 12:54 am
And Cinema Show????????
Ernest
February 11, 2017 at 1:18 am
I’ve been listening to Genesis music for 40 years. Having said that, this are my 20 songs from Genesis (I will try to choose from all the studio albums):
1. Stagnation
2. The Musical Box
3. Supper’s Ready
4. Firth of Fifth
5. The Lamia
6. Squonk
7. One for the vine
8. Snowbound
9. Heathaze
10. Dodo (the live versión from Three Sides Live and if it’s possible the live versión from any bootleg from the Mama Tour when Dodo was the opening track and it was AMAZING)
11. Home by the sea / Second home by the sea
12. Domino
13. Driving the last spike
14. Alien afternoon
15. Inside and out (B-side from Wind & Wuthering)
16. Twilight Alehouse (B-side from Nursery Cryme)
17. Ripples
18. Entangled
19. In the cage (the live version from Three Sides Live)
20. Afterglow (the live version from Three Sides Live)
David Atkinson
February 11, 2017 at 7:50 am
Any list the has ‘Invisible Touch’ or ‘I Can’t Dance’ on it is immediately disqualified.
Antonio Helcio Vilela
February 11, 2017 at 7:29 pm
Cinema show?….
Federico
August 26, 2017 at 5:30 am
Genesis